"TEXT BOOK DEATH"- REACTION FROM "KINGDOM" OF SAUDI ARABIA

THIS IS FROM MEHMOOD, SAUDI ARABIA
Dear All,
While performing his duty, a innocent teacher been assulated and
killed by aggressive muslim youth league workers in malappuram.
Couple of days ago they have burnt millions of worth books,supposed
to distribute to poor pupil, under the leadership of our former education
minister sooppy...
This is too brutal..muslim league party cannot survive without
power. their power thirst made them blind..they are using religion
as a weapon. but they are not aware of the consequences, far reachig problems of muslim existence, country like ours...unfortunately
socalled muslim groups (eg. jamaeth,mujahid) also knowingly or
unknowingly particpating with them..how can they justify their
agitation ? gov. had decided to reform the book.in democratic
system we should have democaratic culture. from the begining itself,
no reason for agitation against the book..remember, when mr c.h.
mohd koya was edu.minister, Umerfarook's carrekecher (spell?) was
appeared in tex book...no protest, no jihad, somebody pontedout and removed the page.
Muslim jihadi group must stop this baseless,illogical agitation with immideate effect. or they have to face the consequences...things
are changing,especially after the death of Mr.Agustine Joseph,
otherwise league leaders and turban group has to pay heavily...
alappuram is changing.. league is a sinking ship..shihab thangals
magic water (his own spited water) cannot save league anymore...

regds/mehmood ( Jubail, Saudi arabia, E mail: kpmehmood@gmail.com)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Opnin:We all agree his suggestion and participate in his feelings in the issue .How ever,it is good to avoid agressive remark on persons like shihab thangal ( he is very innocent person who knows nothing about issue and he is in another "world")
wahab
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

What a Brutal Is This?

BOW OUR HEAD TO THE VICTIM OF
TEXT BOOK VANDALISM

Actually this is very shame in the history Kerala’s education scenario. An innocent teacher,James Augestin, who came punctually to attend teachers’ refreshment course(monthly cluster meeting) have unfortunately loss his life (for much criticized Jeevan) by the kick and suppress of Text Book Jihad mob (arrogant youth League).Mr.Ummen Chandy criticized Govt. for not deploying police force before every cluster meeting premises. In which sense he said this? Does he believe a democratic govt.could deploy police battalion in front of such academic event?


Teacher’ cluster meeting is entirely for teachers and by teachers. What is the role for political party mob or Youth League there? (What is the role of cat in gold market?)


Mr.Ummen Chandy and his colleague Mr Kunhali Kutty should have instructed their party men not to go there and make vandalism.


The 7th class text book is apt for our newly adopted academicals pedagogy. Besides,Govt. had appointed expert committee to reform the book and as per its and curricular committee’s recommendations Govt. has readied to revise the book.


In this circumstance, every one can understand the motive of anti book agitation again. That is to create feeling in minority that if the 7th class book exists, “the religions will be in danger” and to exploit religious communities for their political motive


But what happened finally by the “martyr” of a teacher? Leadership of the League may assess this agitation get them gain or loss. But my humble request to the leaders of non political Muslim Organizations to abstain and end co-operation from this politically motivated or misunderstood agitation for the sake of Islam.


Abdul Wahab,Payyoli



wahabkp@gmail.com

Is music "haram"?

Dear,
Do you like music? Is music a forbidden fruit to us? I wish to qoute here world  legendary musician, Beethovan: " Music is higher revelation than philosophy". May I add to Beethovan this also? ...But Gazal is the sweet flow in the profound river of philosopy.

Some believe music should be kept distance with us in the religious , cultural aspect. can we do ? what is your view ?
pls send, but along with 1 song of your most  selection.(after scanning)
here is some,  pls appreciate.(latr send attachment to your mail)
lovingly ,
wahab

Expert Committee's suggestion is not a Surrendering

The Text book expert committee's suggestion or recommendations are to be welcomed. because it has been constituted by Government and it constis Experts to clear  and to make  the book most suitable to attain carricular objects, at the same time considering the  genuine complaints from  the societiy. The authority  never claimed the book is 100 percent perfect. So that govt. formed the ex.pert committee.It is also a culture of democricy.
But , our opposition parties' aim is another one.I believe , actually they are not took the spirit of its acadamic aspect, modern learning pedogogy etc.
lovingly wahab
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And this is from Hamza Pottindavida, a wel wisher of Kerala's modern learning methedology:



Fine, if there is a recommendation from the committee to remove this lesson from the text book, then, this should be seen in the context of the mayhem created by
all religious bodies, communal and the secular parties alike out of political vendetta
This may not change the basic issues which were highlighted by many progressive writers in this forum. This may not mean that Mr Wahab kp or me are going to propagate or promote mixed marriages and call for a 'Jihad' toward this or would set an example ourselves !
What we were trying to highlight was the need to have tolerance, acceptability, pluralistic thinking and multi cultural co-existence
There would be many who are strongly believing in these lines and India being a secular country need to incorporate some kind of secular thinking process in the educational environment without hurting any particular religious sentiments which the Kerala Education ministry did not do in this context
As I said earlier, we are still teaching Darwin and the Origin of species in our schools which is a direct attack on all established religions as Islam, Christianityor Hinduism consider this as the case for our origin !

All religions have shown a tolerance here and what we need is the same kind of acceptance in other areas
We have a well established Madarasa system which will definitely take care of all "Kufriyaths' taught in our modern schools !

Best Regards/Hamza

INDIAN LEFT SHOWED ITS IDENTITY

What ever the benefit or trap in the Indo-US nuclear treaty, my opinion is that it is great thing that once again Indian Left wing showed its political identity by withdrawing support from Congress led Government. Formerly, left dared to give support to form congress government with the view that Fascist Hinduism’ let not to rule India. That was also their strong commitment on secularism and its beneficiaries is minority community in India, especially Muslims.
In this aspect, it is very thinkable how we can analyze the stand and plays of Muslim League which is everything under a ‘religious’ and spiritual leader. We all blame Left because of their secular, materialistic, and non religion (mathamillatha Jeevan) view.
You say, who is useful to minority and who stand with minority issues and their worries. Is it League or Left?
And which leaders exploit poor minority (muslim) members, League’s or Left’s?
I think, League leaders are not aware about the consequence of Indo-Us nuclear treaty or perhaps they have no any idea about “123 agreement” or “Hydel Act”. When Left was very seriously involving in discussion and arguments against signing up of treaty and giving warning to Central govt., our League leaders are making jihad agitation in Kerala against 7th class book without reading its single page .( it is another story, in fact it is not anti Islam, but in my opinion, it is very pro Islamic: because it promulgate the student for more reading about religions like Islam, ultimately it gains Islam)
At the beginning Left Party warned Govt. not go with nuclear treaty with US because US has always their own imperialistic agenda. Is anybody believed US aim is India’s nuclear development? Contrary, it is said that many traps are in the agreement, among one is to make India’s participation or inaction in US’s proposed Iran aggression.
To make treaty with India US amended section 123 of ‘American Atomic
Energy Act-1954’. (Commonly call 123 agreements)
Beside, to get approval for 123 amendment from Americans a US senator Henry Joseph Hyde presented and passed a bill in American congress ‘Us-India Peaceful Energy Co-operation Act’ (commonly call “Hyde act”.
There are so many section in this act which ignores India supremacy and India’s liberal foreign policy.(*let’s discuss later what are they).
In this context I am very proud about left for their reaction against our govt’s treaty with this imperialistic, anti Islamic power.
At the same time I ashamed with the stand of our’(Muslim)League’ keeping tightly its single minister in power without using
an international opportunity to show its pride and response to oppressed muslims in the world especially in the middle East.
Your response are invited
With love wahab

BUT LEAGUE IS MAKING JOKES

Amidst in the busiest involment in mobilising muslim 'umma' for a jihadi agitation in Kerala against 7 the class text book and collecting books for burning purposes, our Muslim League leaders have been annoyed by some medea persons asking some unwanted questions:
"What is your party's policy about Indo-Us nuclear Treaty?", and "Do your party's ministership quit,if govt. go with the treaty?" or "do you stand against Govt like Left has did?"
To answer these question league leader compelled to gather for a meeting in its leader's residence yesterday.
While they are taking food,some discussion was going on:
Thangal asked to E Ahammed: " Ahamedsahib, What is 123 agreement?"
Ahammed replied: "that is very simple, it is about 3 steps. 1 is the unwanted crisis aginst our ministership (quit or continue), and 2 is about a crucial desicion by our questionable leader, Thangal, and 3 is your decision as usual to continue in ministership with a strong hold".

Thangal noded his head with a smile and started to pray by saying "Al fathiha".
Then every thing ok. Media persons rounded Kunhalikutty for briefing.
(Na oodu billa, I believ thangal is innocent person)

There was also a conversation between Thangal and Kunhali Kutty also:
Thangal asked him: "Yella, Kunhali Kutty sahib, What is hide(Hyde) act?
Kunhalikutty replied: In English hide means covering up or keep secret every thing
from public like me in the ice creame incident".
Thangal again smiled appreciating the ability of Kunhalikutty who over took Goerge Bush
and wispered:"Avan Puliyaanu Kettaa.."
_____________________________________________________________________
Press Note by League: 'It will be very misarable to muslim umma that not early getting their passport if
E Ahammed resigns from mistership for a silly matter"
What about your openion, pls reply, add more by yourself.
regards wahab

7th std book

The row over the 7th standard text book in Kerala is politically motivated by some unacademic politicians. Some political parties only interested in their political gains and not bother about the academic aspect of our schooling. They criticised the book even without reading and understandin the curricular object in the lesson. They must know that the new education pedagogy adopted in Kerala is most innovative inwhich students themselves create knowledge by understanding the situations and evident from the experiment dine by them. Teachers are only fecilitating them for such expiriments and finding outs. In this methode student discusse by group and interact their ideas and create knoledge. Student, unlikely our conventional methode,are not puppets whispering what they hearing from teachers.
This is child centered education not teachers centered like usual type.
Unknowing these devolopment in Kerala's education system, some irrogant political party criticise and disagree with new methodology in our education system which implemnted after long and profound thinking and discussions by able innovative persons with a wide social concept.
This controversy opened a new chapter in Kerala. Some Panchayath dared even to ban this text book in school in their jurisdiction.( Kalpakanchery Panchayath authoritis passed a resolution to ban the book in studying this book) They victimised a politiacal consipiracy even without reading the chapter in the text book.
KeralaGovernment instituted a committee to reviw the book and to suggest what ever in the book as anti academic and anti religion, more anti progress of our society. But our opposition party not willing to cooperate with them without reading of hte book. Their motive is another thing than education of our children.
pls react without prejudice

=====================================================================

here received a comment:

from a NINAN

Is 7th std Book worst than 'Evolution Book'?

It is unfortunate that young men among the new generation born and brought up in the midst of opportunities thanks to the progress of science and technology, become puppets in the hands of wily politicians and religious leaders who have ulterior designs. They brake their bones and shed blood in the name of innocuous text book. Do they know that there are academic books all over the world thousand times more harmful than the class 7th book.
Zoology text books teach evolution which says that man evolved from chimpanzees through mutation and super -activation of the gene prodynorphin
which is responsible for cognitive powers and superior intelligence of man.
This scientific theory strikes at the root of all religions. There was healthy controversy about the theory in Europe in the 19th century. But the vast the majority have accepted the theory and it led to the advance of biological and medical science.
In politics a handful of leaders may get upward mobility when thousands break their bones. Let our younger generation understand that life is more precious than some crumbs of political power. Let them wait for change of power through votes and democratic process in our democracy.
Pls react in this regard,
Wahab : 09288192750 (India)